Threesome Stories – My First Threesome

During college I started dating an amazing girl from one of my classes.  Pretty soon after, we were both head over heels in love with each other.  We had started the relationship out as an informally open one, “I don’t want to be in a relationship yet.  Let’s just do our own thing when we’re apart, and I don’t wanna know who else you’ve been with, just use condoms.”  This was good for both of us for a while, but when real feelings started seeping in, we both became less comfortable with the arrangement and stopped seeing other people.

One evening we were talking about sex and she asked me “Would you want to have a threesome with another girl?”  I knew she was bisexual from the beginning, but I was so naïve that it didn’t even occur to me this was a possibility.  I’m pretty sure I immediately got a boner, and replied “Yup” without hesitation.  Who the fuck would say no???  I mean, isn’t that every guy’s fantasy?  Apparently not, because she was really surprised at my answer.  She told me that every boyfriend she’d had in the past considered it cheating and none of them were up for it.  What?!  How could this be?  Well that’s definitely not me, let’s DO THIS!

The very next day I created a dating profile on OK Cupid to find a girl for us to date.  I loaded good pictures of both of us, separate and together.  I searched for Bisexual girls and sent tons of them messages (I later figured out that this is not the best strategy).  We got a few replies, but nothing came of them.  About two weeks into this experiment I found a girl who called herself a “Unicorn” and said she enjoys being with couples.  Jackpot!  We messaged back and forth, then decided to text instead.  I was working a bunch at the time, so I set up a date for her and my girlfriend to meet for coffee and see if she’s interested.  Pretty good time management if you ask me.  After their date she came home so excited!  This translated to some amazing sex that night. 

We talked it over together and decided on some rules about protection and what we did and didn’t want out of the experience.  This was a great exercise and made the whole thing run much smoother.  It was time for the three of us to meet!

We set up a date near her house (we’ll just call her “Uni”, short for Unicorn, from now on) which was about an hour away.  We all met at a bar, hugged, said hi, got our drinks and then went and sat on a couch in the back.  We chatted for a while together, and everyone was getting along well.  I went to the bathroom to relieve myself and when I came back, Uni was making out with my girlfriend on the couch.  Holy shit.  This is hot.

I just stared at them for a minute, in awe of watching my girlfriend make out with another girl, then I sat down on the couch and put my arm around both of them.  My girlfriend turned around and said “I want to see you two kiss,” then it was my turn to make out with Uni.  She was a great kisser.  We sort of took turns kissing and touching, which was much less awkward than I thought it would be.

My girl excused herself to the bathroom and Uni situated herself on my lap and we kept making out.  How could I be this lucky?  When she came back, she did the same thing I did and just watched us for a minute with a huge smile on her face before rejoining us on the couch.  We talked for a while longer and had a great time together.  We all agreed we should meet up again, but at my house this time (I found out later that going on multiple dates is not necessary if you do it right, but I was new to threesome dating at the time).  We set up a date for the next weekend. 

She agreed to meet us at my place.  We had a whole date planned out which involved a little coastal excursion with wine and cheese, dinner, and of course some bedroom time.  The only problem was that I had a tiny full size bed, barely large enough for 2 people to sleep somewhat uncomfortably…  We decided to head to my girlfriend’s dad’s house and trade out my small full for the queen size in their guest room.  This was a huge pain in the ass, but hey, we wanted to have enough room to really threesome it up! 

When Uni came to my house we all hugged and hopped in the car for our beach date.  It was summer at the time so the beach was just about perfect.  We got a little drunk on cheap wine and watched the sunset together while cuddling, making out, and touching of course.

Once we were back at my house I started making dinner while the girls sat on the couch.  They were kissing, touching, and getting really into it.  I just watched, trying not to get too turned on, and served up some dinner.  I made Cacio y pepe, a simple Italian pasta served in a parmesan bowl, which never fails to impress.

I should mention that none of this was necessary to get to sex.  We were trying to woo a girl that was already happy to fuck us.  It took me quite a few threesomes to realize this.  Don’t get me wrong though, the beach date was fantastic.

While still on the couch, clothing started to come off all three of us.  Uni had great tits, and what was even better was watching them pressed against my girlfriend’s.  We all moved to the bedroom and fell onto our newly acquired queen bed.  I pulled the pants off of each girl, and my GF immediately started kissing Uni’s legs and eating her out.  I took this opportunity to start fucking my girl from behind while watching this little show.  It was like being inside of a lesbian porn video and getting to participate!  It was seriously amazing.

After a while (who knows how long, my mind wasn’t functioning at full capacity), my girlfriend turned around and said “I want to see you fuck her.”  Well, that was all the prompting I needed.  I grabbed a condom and rolled it on.  Both girls grabbed me and lowered me on to the bed and Uni got on top.  She rode while they both made out.  How I lasted through that is beyond me.  What an amazing sight…

I wanted control so we all switched up and Uni started going down on my girlfriend while I pounded from behind.  I had actually never used a condom before this (I was always in monogamous relationships back then), and my little man was not accustomed to the sensation so it started going a bit soft.  This was quite frustrating and I had never experienced this problem before.  After trying and failing to keep it up, I grabbed a cockring and put it on the base of the condom.  That did the trick.

With my newly refreshed manhood I was finally able to go as deep as I wanted, much to the delight of Uni, who was still working her magic on my girl.  I kept watching her writhe in pleasure, and the noises coming from the two women were magnificent.  Things started heating up even more and all three of us, as lame as this sounds, became one in a way, moving in rhythm with each other.  I was getting closer and before I thought those three words, Uni said them.  “I’m gonna cum!”  Still moving in rhythm together, all three of us finished at the same time, something so unexpected it’s hard to grasp how the fuck it happened.  We all collapsed on the bed in a heap of naked, sweaty satisfaction.

Freeman